Skip to main content

About this Show

Hardball With Chris Matthews

News/Business. (2013) New. (CC)

NETWORK

DURATION
01:01:00

RATING

SCANNED IN
San Francisco, CA, USA

SOURCE
Comcast Cable

TUNER
Channel v787

VIDEO CODEC
mpeg2video

AUDIO CODEC
ac3

PIXEL WIDTH
1920

PIXEL HEIGHT
1080

TOPIC FREQUENCY

Colorado 14, Angie 7, The Irs 7, Obama 6, Us 6, America 5, Irs 5, Chad 5, Joe Mccarthy 4, Steve King 4, U.s. 4, Texas 4, Katrina 3, Washington 3, Cuba 3, Peterson 3, Chris Christie 3, Jim Moore 3, Clinton 3, Iowa 3,
Borrow a DVD
of this show
  MSNBC    Hardball With Chris Matthews    News/Business.   
   (2013) New. (CC)  

    August 21, 2013
    2:00 - 3:01pm PDT  

2:00pm
thanks for watching. "hardball" starts now. >> cruzzing for a bruisen? let's play "hardball." >> good evening. i'm chris matthews in washington. tonight, invasion of the body snatchers. the soul of a major american political party is suddenly up for grabs. party of lincoln and the emancipation proclamation of
2:01pm
teddy roosevelt and an american constitution, the american conservation movement, the party of reagan who signed the deal with the so theests that eliminates nuclear weapons could be going ballistic. ted cruz talks in brinksmanship terms about shutting down the american government. he speaks in cold war language of not blinking when it happens. letting the government drop before him as he gazes on in cold contempt. he uses the tactics of joe mccarthy suggesting now defense secretary chuck hagel, a fellow republican, might be an agent of this country's enemies. iran and north korea. will the republican party fight back? will they refuse to let their party's soul be grabbed by this new hard right that harkens back to the worst methods of the early 1950s? will they or let the cruzs and pauls and the rest dictate the new terms of political warfare in this country where no one blinks even when the u.s.
2:02pm
government defaults on its debts, goes bankrupt and leaves the world's creditors to pick up the pieces. michael toe mack second and jim moore is director of progress texas, a political action committee. he was also co-author of "bush's brain." let's talk about this thing now with ted cruz. let's take a look at what happened last night and what happened there. let's talk about republicans by the way, before we get to some of the pictures who care about winning in the future, some of the extreme tactics by people like ted cruz and others like threatening government shutdown in order to defund the affordable care act makes them nervous. mike murphy, here's what he told the washington post. the party, the republican party is acting as if the entire world is a gop primary. that is a very dangerous way to operate. we have massive image problems with the greater electorate. and the silly antics of the purist wing are making our dire
2:03pm
problems even worse. mike murphy is a smart guy. what's cruz up to. >> running for presidency. >> winning the presidency on the hardest right we've seen. >> i wouldn't put him past winning the nomination. he's a very swud guy. he had 1,000 people there last night. he knows what he's saying. picking obama care as his issue to go after, that is the reddist of the red meat for those folks. >> going after a matter of law. it is an act of law. not just obama care. the affordable care act of 2010. let's take a look. here's last night, ted cruz rallied the base as you said against any attempts to compromise on health care or in his words blink. there's the language of the cuban missile crisis. don't blink. let's watch. >> what happens next is president obama and harry reid are going to scream and yell those mean nasty republicans are threatening to shut down the
2:04pm
federal government. what has to happen after that is we've got to do something that conservatives haven't done in a long time. we've got to stand up and win the arguments. if you have an impasse you want to know one side or the other has to blink. how do we win this fight? don't blink. >> jim moore, what's the appeal of that cuban missile crisis lingo where the soviets blinked and they took out their missiles? is it that way now? it's not american politics and debate anymore. it's down to basically cold war brinkmanship. we want to bring down the government to win. >> chris, i think it's the same thing happening here that has been happening all along for senator cruz. he sort of has become the defacto brand for the republican party. and when he starts into this sort of nonsense, he ends up being the image that the rest of america gets about republicans.
2:05pm
and people like lamar alexander and everybody else who is complaining about all of this, they are offering him this vacuum because they are unwilling to anger the folks that are going to vote in the primary by going out and offering some leadership instead, they're letting cruz become their voice to get the base fired up which is good for cruz, but as everybody has suggested, it just isn't good for the republican party and the general election. when you start this stuff about blinking, you end up with confrontation that leaves the country in a standoff mess. >> you're talking about a guy actually running for president and using this language and actually asking the american people i guess implicitly to give him the nuclear football. give him the buttons, give him the codes. a guy like that who talks and thinks like this in these cold war terms given the power to blow us up. i mean, at one point do you separate just good rhetoric and rabble-rousing with possibly governing this country? that's my question to you, jim.
2:06pm
could some people say give him the power? >> well, the problem with this whole don't blink. >> who would say that? >> i think the problem with this whole don't blink ideology and a person who isn't very bright says that. i think mr. senator cruz's intellect is wildly overrated at this point because it's easy to go out and agitate people and get them fired up. but the problem with all of this is, if you're going to sand there and not blink, you end up with a country that doesn't have a government, that doesn't have funding, that doesn't have the services that it normally provides. and if you want to shut down the government, he has the military and everything else to worry about. largely if you ask me, this is wildly irresponsible on his part. and the republican party needs to do something about mitigating what he's doing to their party and ultimately what he could do to to this country and its government. >> cruz said republicans need to turn the argument around on president obama and he says, make him responsible for the government. some weird logic there because
2:07pm
he ininsists on funding this health care law. it's the president's fault he wants to carry out the law. he said the idea the government shutdown was such a bad things in the '90s was is overblown. he's not just talking about a government shutdown. he's talking about default, the chinese asking for our money back, we're finished. >> he's talking about the whole thing. this kind you have rhetoric grossen an grows and builds like a snowball, rolling down the hill. you can't stop it because it demands -- >> why do you think, michael, it's working? why is it working with the angrily nasty right? >> they demand absolute purity. lamar alexander very consecutive voting record. he voted to confirm a couple of these people and boom, that's it. >> let's hear the pitch. ted cruz down in texas the other night. >> if president obama decides that he's going to force a partial temporary government shutdown, and it's worth noting the last time that happened, we
2:08pm
assault number one, the parade of horribles people like to talk about on tv didn't happen. what happened was a temporary suspension of nonessential federal government spending. >> well, that's, of course, what happens if he does blink. of course, what this is ridiculous. playing around with this nuclear button an see what happens. if you don't do it, it doesn't do it. but if both sides take that point of view, what happens? >> then we do have a shutdown. >> and default and it keeps going. >> i think obama is going to stand this time. he knows he caved in 2011. i think he's going to stand a little tougher. most people will blame the republicans. most people know the republicans are saying no to everything and causing more trouble. >> jim you said something. he's not the oldest guy in the world. i was thinking, jim, does he have any history under his belt? he came from an interesting background. i'm with him and his family about having his father's country stolen from him by the communists and cuba. having your country stolen from you isn't something you forget.
2:09pm
i'm with him on that. he has a sense of the blink because that's cuban missile crisis lingo. does eshave a sense of who joe mccarthy was, how tricky the cuban missile crisis ended up to be, how close it came? and it took khrushchev and kennedy to work it out, people did agree to agree under the table to agree with the jupiter missiles in turkey. that's a story of compromise, not blowing up the world or brinksmanship by both sides saying let's not blow up the world. does this guy know that? >> i think, i don't know if he does. i think though that to the extent that your parents experience often infors your politics, we get a twisted sort of thing with him. one is the cuba thing. but on the other hand, he comes into the world into a country with socialized medicine probably at a public system that he is now denouncing in this
2:10pm
country having. but if he has that kind of background, that kind of perspective is, it's been closely held, chris, because he was a solicitor general, a low profile guy. he came out of nowhere. and i think his election ends up being an anomaly simply because of the fact that if it weren't for the runoff, if it weren't for a poorly run campaign by the lieutenant governor and a vote in july and the tea party turnout, he would not have won. >> again, i want to make the point, if you make any reference to blinking in american politics, anybody knows the history of not blinking, goes back to dean rusk, the i think the other side blinked. he decided not to the push it and stand up to the military because he was able to get a concession. you pull your missiles out of cuba, we'll pull them out of turkey. it was under the table and ended up working. i want to go to something that bothers me about this guy. it's the way he's used the tricks of joe mccarthy. i want to go back to what he
2:11pm
said about chuck hagel who is a centrist. he's a moderate republican nebraska. not exactly the westside of new york. he's a moderate. look at the language he used at him when he wanted to shoot this guy down. i've accuses him of mccarthy tactic. here he was at the nomination hearing for hagel back in february and cruz can relied on innuendo and guilt by association. this is mccarthy stuff. >> we saw with his nomination something truly extraordinary which is the government of iran formally and publicly praising the nomination of a defense secretary. i would suggest to you that to my knowledge, that is unprecedented to see a foreign nation like iran publicly celebrating a nomination. >> jim, he went on to say that the guy may have taken money from north korea, too. he may be working for them. this is chuck hagel, our now secretary of defense. he may have been an agent of the
2:12pm
iranians. doesn't he know that kind of talk is not acceptable? that it is joe mccarthy? doesn't he know this? you can't talk like this in america? i accept the fact decent american born in canada, but this kind of talk i don't think is the way we talk in this country. >> your thoughts? >> we have some vial politics down here in texas from time to time. but this, this kind of language has transcended even the things that you see down here. and as you know, chris, the races down here can get about as nasty as they get anywhere. and senator cruz has sort of taken this thing way out to the edge. and he's made the middle very uncomfortable. i'm talking about texas conservatives. i'm not talking about conservatives outside of this state. he's making people very uncomfortable in his home state. >> the chris, he knows what he's doing. he knows exactly what he's doing. you should have seen the right wing on twitter after he said those things about haggle. they fell in love with him then. he knows what he's doing. >> so do we. thank you michael and jim moore.
2:13pm
thank you for coming on for a look at this guy when there's still time to do something about him. the republican party is over for a growing number of actual republicans. now the co-chair confident polk county iowa ef republican party in des moines has resigned because he says the gop has veered too far right for him. and condones hateful speech he says. he's going to talk to us in a moment here. also the scandal that never was and still isn't. we're learning more about progressive sounding groups that were flagged by the irs. and if at first you don't seed, secede ittom terry partiers in northern colorado have decide colorado is too liberal. finally, pin the blame on the donkey. in other words, if you're a republican, blame obama for everything. even if it turns out it was hurricane katrina that happened under w. don't you remember? this is "hardball," the place for politics. la's known definitely for its traffic,
2:14pm
congestion, for the smog. but there are a lot of people that do ride the bus. and now that the buses are running on natural gas, they don't throw out as much pollution into the air. so i feel good. i feel like i'm doing my part to help out the environment. but, dad, you've got... [ voice of dennis ] allstate. with accident forgiveness, they guarantee your rates won't go up just because of an accident. smart kid. [ voice of dennis ] indeed. are you in good hands?
2:15pm
ip we've talked a lot about congress's automatic across the board spending cuts are having very real damaging iraqis on a lot of people around the country. more evidence this week of the extent of that damage. catch this, the department of health and human services reports more than 57,000 children have been forced out of head start through the funding cuts of that program. one of the great programs, head start. head start helps lower income children as you all know under the age of 5 get a leg up so they can start school with the other kids. the biggest hit in head start funding since the program started in '65. we'll be right back. that's bad news.
2:16pm
2:17pm
welcome back to "hardball." we just told but the gop civil war going on with ted cruz leading the attack. now we'll introduce you to some fed sup republicans who are actually leaving the party, including one live long republican county chairman who resigned just recently in
2:18pm
disgust. first there's the former gop staffer and cancer survivor currently without health insurance because of all things, his sleep apnea was considered a pre-existing condition. he says he'll sign unfor the affordable care act and says the gop's fight against the law has left him too displayed to call himself a republican. of the republican threeiatrics he says we have people treating government like a broadway play, some sort of entertainment. and then in virginia, a long-time republican consultant jumped the party. endorsing democrat terry mcauliffe for governor becoming an voozer to the campaign. perhaps most telling of all in the place on the u.s. map that's ground zero for presidential campaigns and that's iowa, in polk county the gop co-chair resigned from the party writing in part i changed my voter registration to independent today. severing all ties to the republican party. i'm disappointed with the republican party at the national level. i'm disappointed with the republican party at the state
2:19pm
level. i'm disappointed with the republican party at the county wide level. i find it increasingly difficult to defend issues and statements made by party leaders and officials from all three levels. the last straw for this former republican, iowa congressman steve king's explanation for why he opposes immigration reform like the d.r.e.a.m. act. >> for everyone who's a valedictorian, there's another 100 out there that they weigh 130 pounds and they've got calves the size of cantaloupes because they're hauling 75 pounds of marijuana across the desert. >> official republican position on marijuana immigration and hispanics. anyway, former polk county iowa gop co-chair chad brown joins me along with the great dana milbank. chad, when id think this steve king thing is so fraught with stuff. here's a guy whose brain puts together this weird simultaneous equation. people come across the border from mexico or somewhere else all of a certain size, but they're that big wide legs that
2:20pm
he compares to of all the fruits in the world, cantaloupe and their carrying 75 pounds of marijuana. i was trying to figure out how much 75 pounds of marijuana would look like. it would be bigger than this whole room. 75 pounds. how does he put his head around all these negative thoughts just to show how much contempt he has for latinos? think he's smiling because i'm smiling. it's weird. it's weird. your thoughts. tell me why you quit the party, by the way. >> well, it was a decision that was very personal for me. i spoke with several friends, family members, a pastor. i felt uncomfortable with a lot of the hateful rhetoric, and with these issues, the immigration issue, for example. it's the rhetoric, and not just from the representative king but social media is everywhere with real just rhetoric that's
2:21pm
hostile. it's one thing to disagree with president obama's immigration plan. i personally disagree with portions of it, but to go after the children to go after immigrants, crossing the border and plus more than half the immigrants don't even cross the border, this he overstay their visas. so it is surprising and ups upsetting and becomes increasingly difficult to back a party that continue oz down this road. >> chad, when did it hit you in the head that the party had shifted? i mean, was it the an rival of obama that just people couldn't stand the idea he's president? what is it that made them flip in the direction that made you say i can't follow these guys anymore? >> well, you know, i've been a lifelong republican. i was very happy to vote for senator dole, senator mccain. i voted for romney in 2012 because i felt that he was the right man for the job between
2:22pm
the two. but i will say that the republican party that used to espouse the big tent of president eisenhower, even president reagan has shifted so far to the right now that it's disturbing really to i felt uncomfortable at several meetings with other republicans because of the rhetoric. and so i decided to make the change. i was looking into it for, oh, several months now. but in particular, the deafening silence of in response to republican representative steve king's remarks. that was the last straw i would say. >> you know, dana, you're pretty good at satire. it's hard to beat the band with this stuff. i sometimes think what's more embarrassing to the gop these days, not in history, the stuff they put in their platform which they don't want to believe anymore about abortion rights and gay rights. so out of date. but the stuff they say in the
2:23pm
back room, the 47% stuff, the obama hates white people, the steve king crazy stuff. you wonder, is it impulsive stuff that just comes out of them or stuff they type out and think about? >> there always seems to be a tape recorder in these rooms. >> it's the bartender sometimes. >> they might want to be wise to this. . what's happening here, this is a reaction to something that's been going on for some time. chad and the others data points here. the republican party has been crumbling for some period of time analogous when the democratic party crumbled in the south. you didn't realize how bad it was until all of a sudden things really started to pick up like this. you've got a lot of people main straet republicans chamber of commerce republicans, the phrase i'm hearing all the time is i'm a republican but. there's like, they're not democrats. you don't hear this man bookkeeping a democrat. but they're saying i don't belong in this party anymore and don't know the quite what to do. they don't seem to have the ability to change it. >> you know, chad, back in the
2:24pm
1950s, a lot of people where i grew up in pennsylvania near the suburbs, we grew up in the city, but near the suburbs a lot of people switches their registration from right wing republican to independent. they felt there was too much right wing action. tell me why you went independent, not democrat. that's interesting. >> well, i'm still looking, but with the independents, i'm still conservative. i would consider myself conservative by 1980s standards. >> let me test you, chad. you're on "hardball" here. suppose chris christie got the nomination for your party. i don't think he's going to get it. i think the party's way too right wring for him. suppose he won the nomination. would you be a republican again? >> i would have to see who the democrats would nominate. >> okay. >> chris christie, that would be impossible. he'll never get the nomination. at least not in iowa. at the caucuses.
2:25pm
there's just no chance, no support at all for him. >> not in your state. forget that. how about if he wins because of new hampshire and other states? how about if it's hillary clinton against chris christie? are you a republican, a democrat or an independent? what are you? come on. >> when i was growing up, it was more about the economy and taxes and now it's my now that i have a child, i look at education. that's very important. i look at the gun issue. the gun lobby, for example. i would have to look at hillary clinton. >> yeah. she's better on guns. you got it. is that the party? that's what you're seeing out there. >> chad is trying to say he's not a democrat. he's not changed to some liberal. he's the same conservative he always was. but even a conservative republican is finding it very difficult to be republican. >> let me tell you what i just
2:26pm
heard there, hillary clinton will appeal to the middle. she's more hawkish than obama. tough on foreign policy and i think she's more with the constituency of the democratic party than obama is. i think the clintons have held strong here in these last five years. anyway, chad brown, thank you, sir. good luck in your party picking and dana and your independents and dana milbank with your sarcasm. starting this coming monday, like five days from now, you can watch "hardball" only at 7:00 eastern, not 5:00 anymore. there's another show on there. ed schultz. we're on at 7:00. please change your viewing habits. it really is important that you give us a shot and give us a 7:00 watch. we're going to start all next week. this is "hardball," the mace for politics. ♪
2:27pm
[ male announcer ] the earth moves around the sun. ♪ but man moves the earth. ♪ with best-in-class torque and best-in-class towing, these are some of the bold, new ram commercial trucks -- built to tilt the axis of capability. guts. glory. ram. so, if you're sleeping in your contact lenses, what you wear to bed is your business. built to tilt the axis of capability. ask about the air optix® contacts so breathable they're approved for up to 30 nights of continuous wear. serious eye problems may occur. ask your doctor and visit airoptix.com for safety information and a free one-month trial.
2:28pm
thto fight chronic. osteoarthritis pain. to fight chronic low back pain. to take action. to take the next step. today, you will know you did something for your pain. cymbalta can help. cymbalta is a pain reliever fda-approved to manage chronic musculoskeletal pain. one non-narcotic pill a day, every day, can help reduce this pain. tell your doctor right away if your mood worsens, you have unusual changes in mood or behavior or thoughts of suicide. anti-depressants can increase these in children, teens, and young adults. cymbalta is not for children under 18. people taking maois, linezolid or thioridazine or with uncontrolled glaucoma should not take cymbalta. taking it with nsaid pain relievers, aspirin, or blood thinners may increase bleeding risk. severe liver problems, some fatal, were reported. signs include abdominal pain and yellowing skin or eyes. tell your doctor about all your medicines, including those for migraine and while on cymbalta, call right away if you have high fever, confusion and stiff muscles or serious allergic skin reactions like blisters, peeling rash, hives, or
2:29pm
mouth sores to address possible life-threatening conditions. talk about your alcohol use, liver disease and before you reduce or stop cymbalta. dizziness or fainting may occur upon standing. take the next step. talk to your doctor. cymbalta can help. it's delicious. so now we've turned her toffee into a business. my goal was to take an idea and make it happen. i'm janet long and i formed my toffee company through legalzoom. i never really thought i would make money doing what i love. [ robert ] we created legalzoom to help people start their business and launch their dreams. go to legalzoom.com today and make your business dream a reality. at legalzoom.com we put the law on your side.
2:30pm
back to "hardball." time for our big sideshow tonight. the nixon library released the final batch of white house tapes today. over 3,000 hours of recordings that cover vietnam, china, and, of course, watergate. historians will be combing through the recordings for a long time to come. we found an oval office conversation that took place between president nixon and a young can george herbert walker bush, the senior bush, the chairman of the republican national committee at the time. listen to how chairman bush broaches the delicate subject of dirty tricks. asking president nixon whether he should divulge the information he has, that is bush has, directly to the president or if he should go to henry peterson who was investigating watergate for the justice department. take a listen. >> would you rather not know details if i told you something or would you rather i tell peterson something that i know. >> no, you tell me. i can tell peterson. >> is he involved because he was in the dirty tricks department.
2:31pm
>> wow. the conversation continues as bush continues to report on the activities of ken rights a former youth director for the campaign but who worked at the national committee at the time of this conversation. >> he said that he was involved in handling large sums of money which cash money. he says that he was involved in doing some espionage on muskie and stuff like that. and he said that. >> what did he do? >> i didn't go into it. i didn't go into it. see i just -- >> i talked to peterson about all that. he said there's no problem on that because everybody's fine with everybody else. they don't use electronic devices. >> i don't know whether he did or not. all i know is -- >> i don't know. >> bugging. there's nixon talking about bugging, electronic snooping. "the new york times" reported that month in 1973, that reitz
2:32pm
had been the pay master for a $450 a month spy group. he resigned four days after that conversation. wow. this keeps coming. the nixon stuff. up next, new information about the reported irs scandal. the reputed irs scandal. you're watching "hardball," the place for politics. she loves a lot of the same things you do.
2:33pm
it's what you love about her. but your erectile dysfunction - that could be a question of blood flow. cialis tadalafil for daily use helps you be ready anytime the moment's right. you can be more confident in your ability to be ready. and the same cialis is the only daily ed tablet approved to treat ed and symptoms of bph, like needing to go frequently or urgently. tell your doctor about all your medical conditions and medications, and ask if your heart is healthy enough for sexual activity. do not take cialis if you take nitrates for chest pain, as this may cause an unsafe drop in blood pressure. do not drink alcohol in excess with cialis. side effects may include headache, upset stomach, delayed backache or muscle ache. to avoid long-term injury, seek immediate medical help for an erection lasting more than 4 hours. if you have any sudden decrease or loss in hearing or vision,
2:34pm
or if you have any allergic reactions such as rash, hives, swelling of the lips, tongue or throat, or difficulty breathing or swallowing, stop taking cialis and get medical help right away. ask your doctor about cialis for daily use and a 30-tablet free trial.
2:35pm
i'm hampton pearson with your cnbc mark wrap. the dow tumbled 105 points. the s&p 500 is down 9. the nasdaq dropping 13 points. stocks tumbled after the federal reserve was closed. it was planning to taper off its bond buying program, but officials are still divided on exactly when. meanwhile, existing home sales jumped 6.5% in july to a new four-year high. a career builder survey finds
2:36pm
49% of workers do not negotiate salaries for initial job offers. that's it from cnbc, first in business worldwide. now back to "hardball." how dare the administration imply that they're going to get to the bottom of it. this was the targeting of the president's political enemies effectively and lies about it during the election year so that it wasn't discovered till afterwards. for years, the president bashed the tea party groups. he was very public against these groups. and on his behalf, be perhaps not on his request, on his behalf, the irs executed a delaying tactic against the very groups that he talked about. >> anyway, welcome back to "hardball." that was darrell issa, head of the house oversight committee as you saw there, he has repeatedly
2:37pm
tried to link the irs's targeting of conservative groups to the white house. he's failed to do it every single time. to this point, his witch hunt has found no witches. not in the white house. the entire narrative of this reputed scandal has gotten hard to follow. is it a scandal? yesterday house democrats released new evidence that the rs was also targeting liberal groups in addition to flagging groups with names like progressive. they also flagged applicants using terms like emerge and a.c.o.r.n., a group on the left associated with liberal causes. issa's camp had dismissed those reports which could be evidence he's using the issue to score political points instead of trying to solve whatever problems there are at the irs. u.s. congressman chris van hollen, my congressman, is on the issue today. he announced he's filing a lawsuit against the irs which would attempt to the clarify the murky tax law which led to this in the first place. he's arguing the law as
2:38pm
originally written says that tax exempt groups must be exclusively involved in social warfare, in other words, no politics. translation if you want to be a tax extent 501 c4, organization, you can't do anything political. van hollen is the ranking member on the budget committee and joins us right now. thank you so much for joining us. i got you this morning. watching you on chuck's show, political rundown. i thought that was the answer, just stop giving any of these tax benefits to people if they're involved in politics. treat them like 501 c 3s. issa is operating in a fact free zone. we know the irs was looking at political groups bothing on the right and the left. why is the irs trying to determine if you as an organization are involved mostly in social welfare activities or political activities? because they have a regulation that says that if your primary purpose is social welfare, then you could also do politics. that regulation as you just said
2:39pm
is totally inconsistent with the way the law is written. the law is clear, if you want to be involved as a 501 c4, you're exclusively involved in social welfare activities. no politics. why has -- this is an old regulation. it's come to matter more since the citizens united case, because what they said was that corporations including non-profits could dump millions of dollars into campaigns. so if they allowed some of this political activity, they could dump millions of dollars. >> one of the nice things having my job, you may resent it, i can't give a political contribution of five bucks. i can't give a nickel. it keeps me simple. people say can you help? i say no, i can't. i don't want people think i've given money. tax loss shuen written that way. >> the law says if you look up your statute, the law stays it you want to be a 5001 c4, organization duck only only exclusively engage in social
2:40pm
welfare activities. somehow, when the regulators back in 1959 wrote the regulations, they totally murdered the plain meaning of the law. they said exclusive doesn't mean exclusive. it means primary. that's the root of the problem. >> the moral issue, people that work hard for a living, work with their hands. they've got to pay taxes. >> that's right. >> why should a group out there playing politics not pay taxes? it seems if you've got a political agenda, pay for it. don't ask the government to pay for it. that gets to the question, you can give all the money if you're wealthy to a politician but you can't get a tax break for it. there's a principle involved. the government doesn't subsidize elections. why did they creep into the woodwork whatever they were called, what organizations got the idea, we got an opening here, an i loophole here and we can start doing politics promoting candidates and not pay taxes. >> well, i mean, the regulation, this loophole left the door open to groups whether you're on the right or the left to do that.
2:41pm
the reason they use this one is because you can do it secretly without telling the public who is funding the campaign. if you want to engage in politics, you can spend as much money as you want. file under section 527. that's all tax exempt. that organization. >> could the president do this, i hate to sound like a real lefty. sometimes they're right. is this something the president could do by executive order? call the irs, stop giving tax exempt status to anybody playing politics. >> certainly the irs. >> why can't the attorney general do this. >> the irs could certainly take review the regulations and say we want to conform the regulation. we petition the irs, some groups did two years ago to do exactly that. they haven't done it yet. which is why you need a lawsuit. >> chris van hollen. for more i'm joined by the greatniate mallika henderson of the "washington post." nobody covers elections and government better than "the washington post." i'm looking at these numbers right now. it just seems to me as right as
2:42pm
the congressman was on the facts i bleen, that the public knowledge is so murky and so confused, there's been so much nonsense thrown. look at this, in june of this year, 47% blame the white house. back in may, a month before it was only 37%. increasingly in this fog of political war, the white house is getting blamed for something they probably had nothing to do with. >> that's right. you've had republicans run a very effective campaign on this issue of the irs and sort of essentially saying that the white house culture of corruption led to this whole scandal at the irs. it turns out not to be much of a scandal. the whole idea the irs was targeting not only tea party groups but progressive groups started to come out in the summer. you feel also that the white house was in some ways caught off guard by this. they came out very slow in some ways to respond to this. you remember president obama had the press conference. he said he learned about the
2:43pm
whole thing in the paper. there's sort of legal reasons why he couldn't comment or know about this early on. but ity republicans have been very effective and now they are doing something else with this and linging the irs to obama care and saying that you know, the irs is going to have access to all of this personal information as they implement obama care, not true. but it doesn't prevent them from using the whole idea of the irs as sort of propaganda. >> a tough question. you saw the movie "the war room," about the '92 campaign. >> i didn't see it. >> it's good. about james carville and george stephanopoulos. they knew how to take care of a candidate. something happened within the news cycle, back again. does the white house have a war room? >> you know, it doesn't seem like they have much of a war room. you've talked about this, chris, the whole idea of this president sort of not really being up for the kind of political engagement that you saw, for instance, from
2:44pm
clinton. he doesn't like the politics part of it. and politics is a tough game. it ain't bean bag. oftentimes you feel like this is a white house that is slow to punch back. and i think in this case with the irs, when you are republicans. >> they should have jumped on it and be said we're going to move on this thing. by the way, if hngt gets in there, there will be a war room. thank you very much. up next, secession fever. some tea partiers in col doll want to break away and form their own state. starting next monday, we're going to 7:00 eastern. i know that means adjusting your evening ritual. tune in at 7:00 eastern for the real thing. "hardball." and this is "hardball." the place for politics. announc] these days, a small business can save by sharing. like carpools... polly wants to know if we can pick her up. yeah, we can make room. yeah. [ male announcer ] ...office space. yes, we're loving this communal seating. it's great. [ male announcer ] the best thing to share? a data plan. at&t mobile share for business.
2:45pm
one bucket of data for everyone on the plan, unlimited talk and text on smart phones. now, everyone's in the spirit of sharing. hey, can i borrow your boat this weekend? no. [ male announcer ] share more. save more. at&t mobile share for business. ♪ loses his computer, exposing thousands of patient records to identity theft. data breaches can happen that easily. we don't believe you should be a victim
2:46pm
of someone else's mistake. we're lifelock. we constantly monitor the web so if any of your personal information is misused, we're on it. ♪ ow. [ male announcer ] call 1-800-lifelock or go to lifelock.com today. you're not going to believe this one. republicans in louisiana want to blame president obama for the government's inept response to hurricane katrina down there. three years before he took office it occurred. well a new ppp ploefl louisiana republicans finds that 29% of the republicans in louisiana say president obama was more responsible for the poor response to katrina. while 28%, one less, pin the blame on george w. bush who was actually president at the time. another 44% to show the murkiness in the big easy say they're not sure who to blame. they can't remember which
2:47pm
president to blame. barack obama of course, was a freshman united states senator in 2005 when katrina blew down the doors of new orleans. while president bush praised his fema chief michael brown, you're doing a heck of a job, brownie. we remember and everybody down there does. we'll be right back. and didn't know where to start. a contractor before at angie's list, you'll find reviews on everything from home repair to healthcare written by people just like you. no company can pay to be on angie's list, so you can trust what you're reading. angie's list is like having thousands of close neighbors, where i can go ask for personal recommendations. that's the idea. before you have any work done, check angie's list. find out why more than two million members
2:48pm
count on angie's list. angie's list -- reviews you can trust. i love you, angie. sorry, honey. and then another. and another. and if you do it. and your friends do it. and their friends do it... soon we'll be walking our way to awareness, support and an end to alzheimer's disease. and that? that would be big. grab your friends and family and start a team today. register at alz.org
2:49pm
every day we're working to and to keep our commitments. and we've made a big commitment to america. bp supports nearly 250,000 jobs here. through all of our energy operations, we invest more in the u.s. than any other place in the world. in fact, we've invested over $55 billion here in the last five years - making bp america's largest energy investor. our commitment has never been stronger. i think we're trying to make a statement to the legislature and the governor who have been extremely tone deaf to the concerns of my constituents in particularly well county but throughout northeastern
2:50pm
colorado. everybody views this as a partisan exercise. many of those commissioners are democrats. >> hmm. we're back. that was weld county, colorado board commissioner mike free man explaining why his county in colorado is making making plans or trying to secede from the state of colorado and form the 51st state. on monday they voted to put secession on the countywide ballot this coming november. that's this fall. weld county is one of several rural counties in northeastern colorado you see it on the map considering secession. progressive legislation passed by democrats who control the governorship and legislature down in denver, things like gun safety and renewable energy measures, ignores the interests of their communities, they believe. seceding from the state of colorado would require more than just a vote by the citizens of the county, obviously. both colorado's state legislature and most importantly the united states congress the senate and the house would need
2:51pm
to approve the partition proposal. bottom line, secession is not likely to happen any time. benji is the "hardball" reporter for msnbc.com. he's been covering the movement and told me about it. and katie atkinson is a consultant in colorado. benji, thank you. you've been enthusing me with this strange story. i heard him say this is a statement. is it a statement simply to poke politically at the people in denver? what's he up to? >> well, as you said, this isn't coming true any time soon. okay? it's fun to come up with the names for it. it's going to be awhile. the context here is that the republican party in colorado is basically ghost of christmas future for the gop. they've been bleeding support from women, latinos, young
2:52pm
voters. they've essentially imploded. democrats have complete control of state government right now for pretty much the first time in generations. they're using it to pass a robust agenda that includes bills on gun control, renewable energy that's really ticked off the rural areas, civil unions. it's a long list. so at its heart this is a political dispute here. it's a jarring situation for some of these voters. kent buck ran as the tea partier in 2010 and blew the election comparing homosexuality to alcoholism. now you have this. but at its heart, one way to approach this is to say we just need to win back those seats and just run a bunch of moderate republicans who could win back those voters. instead they're declaring electoral bankruptcy. let's just leave. >> let me go to katie.
2:53pm
i always found colorado a hard state to get a fix on. you had moderate liberalism out there. and then it went to the right a bit occasionally. what a colorado's politics? is it gary hart? is it hip liberal? is it michael bennett? what is it? >> it swings. i mean, colorado voters, if there's anything colorado voters, it's an extremist. if they think you're extreme on the left or extreme on the right, they won't vote for you. they've been convinced lately that the republican candidates they've been presented with were extreme on the right and they've gone to the left. >> if ken buck had not won that election, bennett would not be the senator out there. >> right. the woman who ran in the primary against him, i think probably could have won that. she was incredibly conservative. the fkt they painted her as a moderate really makes you chuckle. very conservative woman.
2:54pm
but, you know, she might very well have won that race. unfortunately my crystal ball wasn't working at the time so i can't guarantee it. >> you know, the democrats make these mistakes now and then too. they'll run somebody way too liberal and you get jesse helms for 36 years. >> right. both are similar. >> they swing too far. >> right. and that's one of the interesting things here is that they really have given republicans an opening in colorado. john hickenlooper, his approval rating has been dropping. there are signs people are upset with this pace. but unless you win over the swing voters and convince them it's safe to come back -- >> you know what smart politicians do? bill clinton went too far when he went to little rock. then he moved back to the center. hillary called herself mrs. clinton. changed her classes, did things like that. it's your thought about that. it's connecting to the center. >> absolutely. and here's what we're seeing in colorado. probably the worst time to be governor is when both houses
2:55pm
legislature are under the control of your party. i think a lot of what we've been seeing happen at the legislative level is not particularly something the governor wanted to see. the governor's had a difficult time trying to manage the legislature. >> we'll have you back on that. thank you so much. katy atkinson and my colleague here benji sarvin. back after this. a talking train. this ge locomotive can tell you exactly where it is, what it's carrying, while using less fuel. delivering whatever the world needs, when it needs it. ♪ after all, what's the point of talking if you don't have something important to say? ♪ if you don't have someti ng important to say? turn ♪ ed 65 last week. the math of retirement sometis different today.ay? money has to last longer. i don't want to pour over pie charts all day. i want to travel, and i want the income to do it. ishares incomes etfs. low cost and diversified.
2:56pm
find out why nine out of ten large professional investors choose ishares for their etfs. ishares by blackrock. call 1-800-ishares for a prospectus, which includes investment objectives, risks, charges and expenses. read and consider it carefully before investing. risk includes possible loss of principal.
2:57pm
2:58pm
let me finish tonight with this. it's hard to find political sanity these days.
2:59pm
some balanced view of thing that also points to what is best in this country, what's not good, and how to make things better for the future. on this program i've tried to do that. i've tried to support america's interest in the world while realizing the limits on what any good government can do when it comes to our privacy and civil liberties. i've tried to support a woman's constitutional right but also expressed my belief that the best most successful way to reduce the number of abortions in this country which is always a matter of true moral contention, is to reduce the number of unplanned pregnancies and put the focus there. on the responsibilities of those who are in so many cases the people most responsible for unplanned pregnancies were for unprotected sex. men. i believe the pro-life people should spend more time acting on the takeoff and not just the landing. as much time thinking about the men responsible as they do putting heat on the woman less responsible. i try to be balanced in this matter of stop and frisk.
3:00pm
respecting the danger of good police work and our desire especially those of us who live in tough neighborhoods to have police doing their job. which includes respecting the people they take the responsibility to protect. we do it a little different here on "hardball." that's why i want you out there watching when we go exclusively next week to 7:00 eastern. this is important stuff. it's not easy. i need you with me. that's "hardball" for now, thanks for being with us. "politicsnation" with al sharpton starts right now. thanks, chris. and thanks to you for tuning in. tonight's lead, 50 years after dr. martin luther king's i have a dream speech, republicans have their own dream. to impeach president obama. it's the latest sign of just how desperate the gop has become. they lost the election, they don't have an agenda